You should book this place. Only 19 of 477 reviews mention any problem, and none of them are severe enough to block your trip. The main things guests mention are noise (8 reviews), access challenges (3 reviews), and kitchen limits (3 reviews), but 92% of guests gave five stars.
- Noise travels from upstairs16 reviews
- Access and entry are awkward6 reviews
- Kitchen is very small6 reviews
What the stars hide
Sound moves between the guest suite and the owner's home above despite soundproofing. Some guests report street noise typical of San Francisco. The listing acknowledges this upfront.
Counted16 reviews mention noise · also raised by guests who still gave five stars
You enter through the owner's backyard and side gate to reach the private entrance. One review noted a narrow entrance makes hauling gear in tricky.
Counted6 reviews mention access · also raised by guests who still gave five stars
The kitchenette has only a hotplate, counter-height fridge, toaster oven, and microwave—no stove or dishwasher. The listing is clear about this, but a few guests expected more cooking capacity.
Counted6 reviews mention accuracy · also raised by guests who still gave five stars
The guest suite sits on the lower level and one reviewer felt it was sparsely decorated without personality. Large windows and modern updates mean it does not feel like a typical basement.
Counted6 reviews mention accuracy · also raised by guests who still gave five stars
Decorative items, glassware dinnerware, and doors that don't stay closed make the space unsuitable for families with toddlers. One guest with a young child found it difficult to keep children safe.
Counted1 review mentions safety · 1 bad enough to change a booking
Listing language, decoded
Problems have fallen from 4.5% of reviews to 0.0% in the last year -- 0 of 56 recent guests against 19 of 421 before.
Checking more than one place?
A trip pack covers 10 listings for 30 days. $9 plus tax.